Jewelry Supply Reviews

Jewelry Supply has an overall rating of 3.7 based on 31 reviews. Customer feedback on Jewelry Supply is mixed.

3.7/5.0

31 reviews

5 Stars

14

4 Stars

6

3 Stars

3

2 Stars

4

1 Star

4

All Jewelry Supply Reviews (31)
KenyaSimpson
May 29, 2026
"Great selection, but a little overwhelming"
I saw all the jewelry parts and immediately figured I’d find everything I needed, i almost did. There’s a ton to browse through, maybe a bit too much if you’re trying to be quick, but the selection is really good.
may_Dunlap95
May 19, 2026
"Pretty sure I wouldn’t order these again"
I ordered a few findings and beads, the quality just wasn’t what I expected. Maybe I got a bad batch, I’m not totally sure, but some of the pieces had scratches and a couple of the clasps felt really flimsy and bent way too easily. I was planning to use them for gifts, but I don’t feel comfortable doing that now. For me, it just didn’t feel worth the trouble.
Janet_johnson73
May 12, 2026
"My order was mostly fine, and the..."
My order was mostly fine, and the beads I did get were good. I saw one item listed as in stock, so I just assumed I was all set and started planning my project around it. Then it got cancelled later, which was frustrating. Shipping was okay, but I really wish the website inventory was more accurate.
MichaelTaranto_26
May 04, 2026
"Decent support, but the wait and policy stuff is annoying"
They did eventually reply to my email, but it took a couple of days, which felt slower than it should’ve been. The response was okay, not rude or anything, but I kind of got the sense they lean on little policy loopholes instead of just giving a straight answer or fixing the issue quickly. Not the worst support I’ve dealt with, but definitely could be faster and less frustrating.
annaarthur5482
April 27, 2026
"Tools are holding up good"
I’ve been using these for a few months or so now, and they’re still holding up well. They feel sturdy enough and haven’t really given me any issues yet...
henry.Koverman
April 19, 2026
"Easy to Find What I Was Looking For"
I had a really solid experience using the site. The categories were well organized, the search function actually did its job, which I appreciated. Checkout was straightforward too. I didn’t have to waste time clicking all over the place just to find basic jewelry supplies. Overall, it was a smooth and convenient process.
DanGarcia_16
April 18, 2026
"A lot of the basics weren’t available"
I was trying to pick up a few basic jewelry supplies, but a bunch of what I needed was out of stock. Some items were still listed on the site, but there wasn’t any clear info on when they’d be back, which seems like something that should be easy enough to include. It was annoying since I was just trying to finish a project. I might check again another time, but this visit wasn’t very useful.
RobertDawson
April 06, 2026
"Pretty consistent beads and findings!!"
Most of the beads and findings were really close in size and color, which was great!! There were a couple of tiny odd ones mixed in, but nothing that caused any issues. Ordering was easy, and I’d definitely buy from them again.
Juan-marquez
April 01, 2026
"Pretty reliable for my bead orders"
I got my beads without any problems, and everything was pretty much as expected (which is all I’m asking for). No complaints from me
derekschneider6975
March 28, 2026
"I ordered a few necklace busts and..."
I ordered a few necklace busts and ring trays from Jewelry Supply, i felt relieved when I opened the box because they looked much nicer than I was expecting. The velvet has a soft, good-quality feel to it, not that thin cheap kind, and the stands actually hold their shape well.
I use them for my little booth setup, and they just make the whole table feel more put together, which makes me feel better about showing my pieces. Nothing came bent or scratched, so that was a big plus too. I’d definitely order more display items from them.
AlessandraFink_81
March 17, 2026
"It got here faster than I thought it..."
It got here faster than I thought it would. I had reached out to support just to check on the timing, and they basically said something like, “It’s already on the way, you should see it soon.” Sure enough, it showed up really quickly. No complaints from me.
Joseph_roche83
March 15, 2026
"Missing pieces and now I don’t really trust ordering again"
My order showed up with some of the beads missing, and one of the charms was bent when I opened the package. I tried reaching out to get it fixed, but the whole process dragged on way longer than it should have. It’s frustrating because I was excited for this order, but now I don’t feel like I can trust them to send everything properly next time
david_Simmons03
March 12, 2026
"Found the right clasps quickly"
I was able to find what I needed fast. The search worked well, and the filters made it easy to narrow down the right clasps without scrolling forever. I had a quick question too, and support was basically like, “try filtering by size and finish first,” which actually helped.
KODADEK
March 10, 2026
"Pricing made me second-guess shopping here"
I ordered a few basic jewelry supplies from Jewelry Supply, and at first I thought the prices seemed reasonable enough. But once I added everything to my cart and checked out, it started feeling a lot less like a good deal.
What bothered me more was finding similar items elsewhere later for less. It made me feel like I should’ve compared more before ordering, and it chipped away at my trust a bit.

The quality wasn’t awful or anything, but it didn’t really match what I ended up paying. I’d probably look around other places first next time instead of assuming the prices here are fair.
MicheleGraves_83
February 27, 2026
"Took a Little While to Ship"
I ordered a few small jewelry supplies, everything was fine once it arrived. The items were what I expected, so no real complaints there.

The only thing was the processing time. It sat for a few days before it actually shipped, and yeah, that was a little annoying. Not the worst experience, but I do wish it had moved a bit faster...
DUQUETTE
February 23, 2026
"Easy tracking and no surprises"
I ordered some jewelry supplies, and compared to a few other places I’ve bought from, the tracking was really easy to keep up with. The updates came through quickly, and I could see when it shipped and where it was, so I wasn’t left guessing if it was sitting somewhere or delayed.
The package showed up right when it said it would, which I always appreciate. Everything was packed well and in good shape too. It was a simple order, but those are the best when they just go smoothly, so I’m happy with the experience.
kelly-Harris
February 23, 2026
"I was impressed with how fast they fixed my order"
I had an issue with my order, i was expecting it to be a hassle. But in my experience, support handled it really quickly and got everything sorted without much back and forth.
DaleCollins_31
February 13, 2026
"Checkout had way too many steps"
I had a few things in my cart and was ready to buy, but the payment options just didn’t work for me. I was hoping to use PayPal or some quick checkout option, but everything felt like it took too many steps and I couldn’t find an easy way to pay. The whole checkout process felt outdated and kind of frustrating, so I ended up giving up and leaving without placing the order. For an online store, paying should be way simpler.
carolyn_Cannon97
February 07, 2026
"Checkout was easy, but I’m a little wary now"
The checkout process was simple and quick, which I appreciated. That said, a few things around the experience made me feel less confident than I expected, so I’m not sure I fully trust it yet.
james_Engel04
January 30, 2026
"Pretty straightforward and easy to follow"
I figured there might be some back-and-forth or confusion like usual, but they explained everything clearly and got back to me quickly. Made the whole thing a lot easier than I expected.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Jewelry Supply?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.